Fall 1950 found me in the first grade at Garretford Elementary school in Drexel Hill, a suburb the Philadelphia, where my class was law duck-and-cover exercises in anticipation of a atom attack. Russia tested the atomic bomb the year before, and that summer north Korea got into the South, beginning the korean War.

You are watching: Communism is a red herring


In Washington, the house Un-American activities Committee to be holding hearings, and Sen. Joseph McCarthy was on a search for communists in government. It was a tense, dangerous time in a danger world. It was no time to speak that socialism or anything that hinted that it.


Socialism implied communism and disloyalty and fifth-columnists and also legions that dour apparatchiks plot the destruction of our country and also our means of life. Civilization were frightened. Us came an extremely close to people War III.


I was there, and I remember, yet that was then, this is now, and also we live in a different people — a world, country and political and also economic setting that’s devolved into something mine parents and also grandparents i will not ~ believe possible and wouldn’t understand, if they to be still here.


Last month i wrote around gaslighting and how words in different contexts and also different associations can be deceiving. Right here are 2 more: red herring and also socialism. Merriam-Websiter specifies a red herring together something the distracts attention from the real issue. "It might be one of two people a reasonable fallacy or a literary an equipment that leads reader or audiences toward a false conclusion," the Wikipedia web page says.


Webster likewise defines socialism together “any of miscellaneous economic and political theories advocating collective or governmental ownership and management of the means of production and distribution of goods.”


Socialism, for this reason defined, is one ideology. The is additionally a red herring when offered as a distraction from our finding options to the difficulties of health care, revenue inequality and also climate change. How frequently do us hear, particularly from 1600 Pennsylvania Ave. And also some politicians, the an idea is socialistic and therefore un-American?


Ideological thinking and accusations don’t settle problems. They encourage divisiveness and also make castle worse. Part politicians thrive on them. It might be good for them, yet it doesn’t lead us to agreement or the typical good.


Socialism is a fear word they have hurled at every advance the world have make in the critical 20 years. Socialism is what they called public power. Socialism is what they referred to as social security. Socialism is what they called farm price supports. Socialism is what lock called bank deposit insurance. Socialism is what they dubbed the expansion of totally free and independent labor organizations. Socialism is their name for almost anything that helps all the people.


Harry Truman was no socialist, nor to be Franklin Delano Roosevelt or his cousin, Theodore Roosevelt, who before him called for a system of national health and wellness insurance in the election campaign of 1912.


In his 1944 State the The Union, Franklin Roosevelt wrote, "Necessitous men are not cost-free men,” and also called because that a second, financial bill of civil liberties that would certainly guarantee every citizen:


The best to a useful and also remunerative job in the industries or shops or ranches or mines of the Nation.

The appropriate to earn enough to carry out adequate food and clothing and recreation.

The appropriate of every farmer come raise and also sell his commodities at a return which will offer him and also his family members a kind living.

The best of every businessman, big and small, to profession in an environment of liberty from unfair competition and domination through monopolies at residence or abroad.

The ideal of every family to a kind home.

The appropriate to adequate medical care and also the possibility to accomplish and enjoy great health.

The appropriate to adequate protection from the financial fears of old age, sickness, accident, and also unemployment.

The right to a great education.

All the these civil liberties spell security. And also after this war is won, we have to be ready to relocate forward, in the implementation of this rights, to brand-new goals of person happiness and also well-being.

America"s very own rightful ar in the world depends in big part upon how fully these and comparable rights have been lugged into practice for our citizens. For unless there is security below at house there can not be lasting tranquility in the world.


That to be 1944, the year ns was born. Seventy-five years have gone by, and also FDR’s an obstacle is still v us in the concerns we space debating today. That dispute is a speak to for pragmatism, no socialism or conservatism or red herrings or gaslighting or rhetorical tricks. It’s around open mental and vital attitudes.

See more: A Game In Which Each Player Adopts Its Dominant Strategy Solution Vs


It’s about the typical good. Words have meaning. Stop be cautious how we use them.